Cities don’t always grow around one central business district. The Harris-Ullman model shows how airports, universities, ports, and other hubs can form distinct centers of activity, shaping nearby housing and jobs. See how this polycentric pattern differs from growth along corridors in the Hoyt model.

Multiple Choice

In which model does urban growth occur around several separate centers rather than a single CBD?

Growth around several separate centers reflects a polycentric urban form. The Harris-Ullman multiple-nuclei model describes cities that develop around more than one center of activity—secondary business districts near ports, universities, airports, or other hubs—so economic activity and housing cluster in several nodes rather than a single central business district. This happens as transportation advances, land values shift, and different functions locate near specialized amenities, creating a network of centers that are connected but distinct. In contrast, the Hoyt model imagines growth in sectors or wedges radiating from the CBD along transportation corridors, not multiple centers. Gentrification describes neighborhood change and displacement dynamics, not a structural model of city growth. Inclusionary zoning is a housing policy tool, not a description of urban form. So the model that accounts for growth around several centers is the Harris-Ullman multiple-nuclei model.

Cities rarely grow in a perfectly tidy way. A downtown may still hold banks, offices, and government buildings, while a university district, airport, port, or shopping hub draws people to other parts of the city. This pattern is known as polycentric urban growth: development gathers around several centers rather than just one central business district (CBD). The Harris-Ullman model gives this kind of city a clear explanation.

One city, several centers

The Harris-Ullman multiple-nuclei model was developed by geographers Chauncy Harris and Edward Ullman in the 1940s. Their idea was simple but important: a city doesn’t always expand outward from a single downtown. It can form around several distinct “nuclei,” or centers of activity.

A nucleus might be a major employment district, a university, a port, a regional hospital, or a cluster of factories. Each center draws certain land uses and services toward it. Homes, shops, and workplaces then form nearby, shaped by the needs of the people and organizations based there. Over time, these clusters may grow large enough to become recognizable districts in their own right.

Think of a city as a collection of connected neighborhoods, each with its own pull. Downtown might attract office workers and visitors. A university area may support student housing, cafés, bookstores, and research labs. Near an airport, hotels, warehouses, and transport firms may cluster. The centers don’t have to be equal in size, and they don’t have to compete directly. They simply serve different roles within the wider urban area.

That’s a useful shift in perspective. Instead of imagining one central point surrounded by rings of development, the multiple-nuclei model treats the city more like a network.

Why do new centers appear?

Several forces can encourage urban activity to gather around more than one hub. Transportation is a big one. Roads, rail lines, shipping routes, and airports connect people and goods across a region. When travel becomes easier, businesses and residents may settle beyond the old downtown and still stay connected to it.

Land costs also play a part. Central areas often have high rents and limited space. A firm that needs large buildings, parking, or room for deliveries may find a better fit on the edge of the city, near a highway or freight route. Other organizations seek specialized surroundings: a hospital benefits from links to medical services, while a university often attracts research companies and student-focused businesses.

These location choices can reinforce one another. A new employment center brings workers, which can support shops and restaurants. More services make the area more attractive to residents. In turn, a larger local population can encourage new employers to move in. A small cluster grows into a stronger node—not overnight, but through many decisions made over time.

This does not mean every new hub is planned from the start. Some develop through public investment, while others emerge gradually as firms, households, and institutions respond to changing costs and transport links. Cities are shaped by policy, but also by thousands of choices that no single planner fully controls.

A different picture from the Hoyt model

Another well-known way to describe urban growth is the Hoyt sector model. It focuses on wedges, or sectors, that extend outward from the CBD, often following transport routes. For example, higher-income housing might stretch along a pleasant corridor, while industrial land follows rail lines or other freight connections.

The contrast is helpful. The Hoyt model emphasizes sectors radiating from a main center. The Harris-Ullman model emphasizes several centers, each with its own surrounding land uses. Real cities can show features of both. A city might have clear corridors of growth and multiple business districts at the same time.

That overlap matters because urban models are simplified maps of complicated places. They help explain patterns, but they don’t capture every street, policy decision, or historical event. No city fits perfectly into one diagram. A map is useful precisely because it leaves out some detail; the trick is knowing what it can and can’t tell us.

The city’s centers have different personalities

Polycentric cities are not just downtowns copied and pasted across a region. Their centers often have distinct jobs and rhythms. A central business district may concentrate finance, public administration, and cultural venues. An airport district is shaped by passenger travel and cargo. A university center may have a strong calendar cycle, with quieter streets during holidays and fuller ones during term time.

These differences can be seen in daily life. Commuters may travel to downtown for one kind of work and to a medical campus for another. A suburb may have its own office parks and shops, so some residents can work closer to home. The same person might use several city centers in a week without thinking much about it.

Polycentric growth can reduce pressure on a single downtown, and it may bring jobs and services closer to some neighborhoods. But it can also create new challenges. If hubs are spread far apart and linked mainly by car, residents without cars may find it hard to reach work or essential services. Traffic can build up around several centers instead of just one. Strong local hubs can also deepen differences between neighborhoods if investment and public services remain uneven.

Transport connects the dots

A network of centers only works well when people can move between them. Rail, bus, cycling routes, and safe walking links can connect districts without forcing every trip onto crowded roads. Frequent transit is especially useful when jobs and services are spread across several hubs rather than concentrated downtown.

Yet transport planning can be tricky. A route that carries people into the CBD may not serve a cross-town trip very well. Someone traveling from one outer district to another might have to ride into the center and back out again. That can make a short journey feel surprisingly long.

Cities can respond by building routes that link hubs directly, improving local bus networks, or creating mixed-use areas where daily needs are close at hand. These changes do more than shorten trips. They influence which locations businesses consider useful and which neighborhoods feel connected to the wider city.

Land use, housing, and change

As new centers grow, the surrounding land often changes too. Warehouses may give way to offices, or older housing may become more attractive to developers. New jobs can bring new residents, while rising demand can push up rents and home prices.

This is where wider urban issues come into view. Gentrification, for example, describes changes in a neighborhood as investment and higher-income residents move in, sometimes putting pressure on long-term residents. It is not a model of city structure; rather, it is a social and economic process that can happen near downtown or around a growing secondary center.

Housing policy can influence who gets to live near jobs and transit. Inclusionary zoning is one policy tool that may require or encourage affordable homes within new developments. Its effects depend on local rules, market conditions, and how well the policy is carried out. In a polycentric city, these choices matter at more than one hub. If affordable housing appears only far from major employment, workers may face long and costly commutes even when the city has several centers.

Reading the pattern, not forcing the fit

The Harris-Ullman model remains useful because it helps explain why urban activity can gather in separate clusters. It draws attention to specialized locations, transport links, land prices, and the way one center can support the growth of another.

Still, cities keep changing. Remote work, online shopping, new transit lines, and shifts in industry can alter which places attract jobs and visitors. Some downtowns have lost office activity while gaining homes and cultural uses. Some suburban centers have grown into major employment districts. Others remain mostly residential.

The key idea is not that every city has a fixed number of nuclei. It’s that urban growth can be distributed. A city may have one dominant CBD, several smaller hubs, and corridors linking them—all at once. Seeing those patterns makes it easier to understand how land use, transport, housing, and economic change shape the places people call home.